The Menu
Classic Cocktails
Old Fashioned
This Classic was founded in 1895. We've chosen Knob Creek 120, added a Luxardo cherry, a muddled orange slice, bitters, and sugar cubes!
$10
Barrel Aged Manhattan
Rumored to have been created at the Manhattan club in NYC in the early 1870s! Our Cocktail is crafted with Redemption Rye, sweet vermouth, bitters and a Luxardo cherry, then aged to perfection in-house.
$10
Whiskey Sour
Our whiskey sours are crafted the old fashioned way! We use egg whites, freshly squeezed lemon juice, simple syrup and bourbon! For a fun, modern twist, you can always request a flavored whiskey. Our house favorite is the Blackberry Whiskey Sour!
$10
Signature Cocktails
Jolly's Golly Gee
Our take on a sweet vanilla rootbeer float! We use TIffin's own Jolly's Rootbeer, Crown Royal Vanilla, and Buffalo Trace Bourbon Creme! Topped with freeze-dried Toft's vanilla ice cream! It will make you say Golly Gee!
$10
Candy Crush Punch
If you have a sweet tooth, this drink is for you! Smirnoff Strawberry mixes with cranberry juice, orange juice, sprite, garnished and rimmed with crushed skittles that were free-dried in house by Freeze Dried Ohio!
$10
The Buchanan
We named our cocktail after Daisy Buchanan from The Great Gatsby! Made with Pendleton Whiskey, Hazelnut Liqueur, and Amaretto. Garnished with a Renaissance's chocolate coin made locally in Tiffin by Neumeister's Candy Shoppe!
$10
Build-A-Mule
Moscow- Wheatley Vodka Kentucky - Buffalo Trace Bourbon Irish - Jameson Irish Whiskey Bermuda - Captain Morgan Rum Mexican - Jose Cuervo Silver Tequila Ask about our flavor options!
$10
Martinis
Build Your Own Classic Martini
Vodka / Gin • Dry / Extra Dry • Dirty / Extra Dirty
Choose one, or none:
Citrus Twist / Martini Olives / Martini Onions
Premium Extras:
Three Blue Cheese Stuffed Olives $1
$10
Specialty Martinis
Cold Brew Coffee Martini
Lavender Lemon Drop
Chocolate Peanut Butter Martini
Chocolate
Add a chocolate coin to any drink for $1
$11
Red Wines
1924
Cabernet Sauvignon
$8
Menage a Trois
Red Blend
Jammy, ripe, rich berry notes.
$8
Barefoot
Pinot Noir
Full-bodied, wild raspberries and sweet cherries.
$8
The Velvet Devil
Merlot
Dark fruit, cedar, pipe tobacco and earth
$8
White Wine
13 Celcius
Sauvignon Blanc
An award winning New Zealand wine. Citrus, lychee, sweet herbs, and a refreshing finish
$8
Woodbridge
Chardonnay
Ripe pear and apple with hints of vanilla and oak.
$8
Risata
Moscato d'Asti
Juicy stone fruit, tart citrus and floral honey.
$8
Schmitt Sohne
Riesling
Peach and fine apple aromas with a hint of citrus.
$8
Menage a Trois
Pinot Grigio
Fresh and fruit-forward, with zesty tropical fruit aromas.
$8
Val D'oca
Prosecco
Fragrant aromas of white stone fruits, apple and wild flowers.
$8
Small Plates
Chips & Dip
Tiffin's Ballreich Chips and french onion dip
$8
Cheese & Crackers
Assorted cheese and crackers plate
$12
Jumbo Pretzel & Beer Cheese
Warm jumbo pretzel served with a side of beer cheese